Internet Fanclub roteteufel.de

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

For an evolution of the arbitration

  • Ersteller Ersteller Guest
  • Erstellt am Erstellt am
G

Guest

Guest
Hello, I'm a french fan of Ogcnice. Please read it. Sorry for my english.



I write in this area because that is very important for the world football. Some Ogcnice's fans have written a petition against actual arbitration. They wanted first to do it only for the french championship but finally I have translated in order to european and world teams fans sign it to move the things.



Please sign it and the moderators, can you put as an hot subject because that 's very important. If there are many people who sign it, that will be better.



For an evolution of the arbitration :



After many errors of arbitration happened these last times on all fields in France, an evolution of the arbitration seems to be imperative. This in order every actor of a game ( players, fans, coaches and referees ) could live their passion and their job in the best conditions as possible.



Lately, referees, for different reasons have taken decisions more than litigious, these decisions having sometimes big consequences as in the game Strasbourg-Monaco (14/08/2005, Day 3 of the French premier league ) and Nice-Sochaux (same day ) in which the referee has said the ball had been taken by the hand of an Ognice’s player and that was the knee with what this player touched the ball. He whistled a penalty an gave a red card to the player incriminated.



These examples are in the French premier league because we are french people but we are sure that in every championship there are errors of this type during which the video could have helped the referee to take the right decision.



The aim is not in order to protest against the referees themselves but to mobilise itself in order to this kind of errors does not reproduce anymore. Referees are the target of these errors but the fault is not only from them. It is urgent, for the shows on the fields, to take decisions in order to the arbitration is as well as possible. Why don’t’ we put in place the video to avoid this kind of errors ? Why do we conserve three referees and a fourth one who doesn’t act a lot ? We could add one in the penalty area. That is for this reason that we have to react, because we are us, the fans, who can make the things to move because an evolution will not come from the European and world authorities. All the fans of football teams of all the world and football lovers can act together in order to move the things.



In this optic, we organize a petition in the aim to ask to the UEFA and the FIFA to put in place the video for all championships games of the whole world. The financial problem should not be a problem because there is a lot of money in every authorities which can serve for that.



Please sign the petition to make the world football moving in this site :

http://www.petitiononline.com/ix5qq3/petition.htmlhttp://www.petitiononline.com/ix5qq3/petition.html



Thanks a lot.
 
ne, sorry, aber da bin ich gegen
default_icon_wink.gif
 
Wenn ich das richtig übersetzt habe, dann irgendwas mit videobeweis. Weil die schiedsrichter in frankreich bei schweren fouls sehr oft falsch enscheiden.
 
arbitration bedeutet hier so etwas wie entscheidungsfindung/fällung. und das will er/sie verbessern durch viedeobeweis.

äh, neee, du, find ich nich gut. wer will denn sowas?!?
 
Ja gut ein spieler von denen hat wohl den Ball mit dem Knie gespielt der schiri dachte er wäre die Hand und hat rot und nen Elfer gegeben...nunja videobeweis ist son ne viel diskutierte sache wird sich eh nicht durchsetzen...There are too many problemes to organise a video arbitration...i'm ngainst it too.
 
Ich bin contra Videobeweis. Ist alles gut so wie es momentan ist. Sonst dauert ein Spiel anstatt 90 Minuten 105 Minuten wenn wegen jedem Videofilmchen unterbrochen werden muss.



Ist auch eine Kostenfrage, denn die unteren Ligen haben nicht das Geld dies einzuführen.
 
Please can you speak in english because I can't speak german. Are you for or against this petition ?
 
We are against video arbitration in ther german soccer leaque!!!!!





Odder?????
default_icon_cool.gif
 
Yes, we are against this, because there are too many open questions.



How shall we pay this?

Which Leagues are involved (1. Bundesliga, 2. Bundesliga, Regionalliga...)?

Should the referee watch every unclear situation - how much time will be spent for this?



Of course there are many mistakes. Nearly every Saturday there is at least one team furious wth the referee.

But that's the game.



I guess your player with the red card (hand -> knee) won't get a hard punishment.

In Germany players with an injust red card have to miss one match in most cases. That's it.
 
besides the technical problems of this kind of arbitration, i don't want football to become like american football. i don't want the game to be paused to make a decision the whole visitors and fans don't know why it is made. i think its ok having that chip in the ball-thing to really be sure if the balls behind the goal line, and i find it allright to punish players afterwards for unfair game oder that players can redeem themselves afterwards with the help of videotakes. but i don't want these kinds of decisions to disturb the game.
 
Finally our player won't miss the next game. The commission said that the video was showing there wasn't fault.
 
Zurück
Oben